Common Ledger is independent and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by PayHOA or Smartwebs. Product capabilities, packaging, integrations, pricing, and service terms change. Claims below were reviewed against provider materials on October 26, 2026; verify current details directly with each provider. This article is general operational education, not accounting, tax, audit, legal, investment, cybersecurity, or CPA advice.
Quick answer
PayHOA currently presents an all-in-one platform for self-managed associations and management companies. Its documentation describes owner billing and payments, general-ledger reporting, receivables, payables, bank connections, transaction matching, permissions, documents, communications, requests, and other HOA workflows. Its help center also documents report packets and a Financial Account feature that is currently in beta.
Smartwebs currently offers a Core Management package and a MAX Management + Accounting package. Its accounting pages describe general ledger, owner receivables, accounts payable and approvals, banking and reconciliation, budgets, reporting, statements, collections, resale, lockbox, and cost centers. Its public pricing page is quote-based and says minimums and implementation fees apply.
That makes this an operating-model decision. A self-managed board, a professional manager, and an outsourced accounting team can use the same software very differently. Compare who performs the work, who reviews it, what evidence the board receives, and what happens when a transaction does not follow the happy path.
Compare the complete model
| Decision | PayHOA questions | Smartwebs questions |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer and package | Which association and financial modules are included for this unit count and operating model? | Is Core or MAX proposed, and which management and accounting functions are included? |
| People doing the work | Will volunteers, a manager, PayHOA services, Common Ledger, or another provider execute and review accounting? | Will the management company, association staff, Smartwebs-related services, or another provider execute and review accounting? |
| Financial close | Who reconciles every account, reviews owner ledgers, closes the month, and prepares the packet? | Who owns those same deliverables and resolves exceptions in the proposed MAX workflow? |
| Total cost | Confirm subscription, implementation, payments, banking, mailing, filing, support, cleanup, and service fees. | Confirm package minimums, implementation, users, modules, payments, lockbox, support, migration, and service fees. |
| Exit rights | Test structured exports, attachments, audit history, credentials, integrations, and final-close support. | Test the same records and identify which data or workflows depend on a management-company account. |
Give both finalists the same month-end test
A product tour can look complete while avoiding the association's hardest work. Provide anonymized sample facts and require each finalist to demonstrate the full cycle:
- Post regular assessments, a special charge, a credit, a prepayment, and a prior balance to the correct owners and accounts.
- Receive an online payment, mailed check, returned payment, partial payment, and initially unmatched deposit.
- Process a vendor invoice through intake, duplicate review, coding, approval, payment release, and cleared evidence.
- Record an operating-to-reserve transfer and a reserve-funded project invoice without double-counting the movement.
- Reconcile every bank and payment account to independent statements and explain old outstanding items.
- Produce the actual month-end board packet and trace a material balance back to transaction support.
- Correct an error while preserving the original activity, authorization, correction, and explanation.
For every step, record the responsible role, reviewer, deadline, approval rule, exception queue, retained evidence, backup person, and price. Software can route the work; it does not create accountability by itself.
Test owner ledgers and cash application
Owner-account accuracy is the center of association accounting. Test a current owner, former owner, multi-unit owner, prepaid owner, partial payer, payment-plan account, disputed charge, legal account, returned payment, and unit transfer. Confirm that the owner statement, receivables aging, deposit record, general ledger, and collection status agree.
PayHOA's current documentation includes accounts-receivable, prepaid, general-ledger, and delinquency reports. Smartwebs describes recurring charges, online payments, collections, lockbox options, statements, and owner-account workflows. Ask each finalist to show how an unmatched payment is found, how a misapplication is corrected, how a returned payment is handled, and how the board can review the evidence without receiving unnecessary personal information.
Distinguish connectivity from reconciliation
A bank connection or imported transaction is not a completed reconciliation. For every operating, reserve, investment, lockbox, and processor account, require a monthly package showing the statement balance, book balance, cleared activity, deposits in transit, outstanding payments, adjustments, completion date, preparer, reviewer, and source statement.
Ask both providers to handle a disconnected feed, duplicate import, stale check, processor timing difference, transfer posted to only one account, and bank fee outside the normal rules. The board should see an exception, explanation, owner, and due date. It should never be asked to accept a permanent unexplained difference.
Map invoice approval and payment authority
PayHOA Payables currently describes centralized invoice intake, approvals, vendor payments, external-payment recording, and scheduled payments. Smartwebs describes accounts payable, invoice approvals, check and payment workflows, and accounting reporting. Those product descriptions are a starting point, not the board's control design.
Require a role map for vendor setup, tax information, invoice intake, duplicate review, coding, contract and budget review, approval, release, bank authority, and post-payment review. Test a new vendor and an emailed bank-change request. A strong process independently verifies changes using a trusted contact method and prevents one person from controlling setup, approval, release, and reconciliation.
Compare reports the board will actually receive
PayHOA's report documentation lists balance-sheet, owner receivable and prepaid, general-ledger, delinquency, and other association reports. Smartwebs describes a report and packet engine alongside budgets, financial statements, receivables, payables, and general-ledger functions. Ask each finalist for an anonymized packet from a community similar in size and complexity.
The packet should explain cash, liabilities, fund balances, income and expense, budget variance, owner receivables, prepaid assessments, unpaid bills, reserves, capital projects, and material exceptions. Record who prepares it, who reviews it, when the month closes, how post-close corrections appear, and which decisions the board must make. A large report library is not useful if directors cannot tell whether the books are reconciled.
Test permissions, recovery, and board visibility
PayHOA documents read and edit permissions by module, including report access. Smartwebs should be demonstrated with the exact roles and package proposed. Test president, treasurer, director, committee member, homeowner, accountant or auditor, vendor, manager, and system administrator.
Identify who controls the primary tenant, subscription, recovery email, multifactor method, bank connections, payment processor, domains, integrations, and vendor-support relationship. At least two currently authorized association representatives should understand the recovery path without sharing credentials. Confirm how former directors, employees, managers, and vendors are removed and how privileged access is reviewed.
Price the work, not only the license
Request a three-year cost schedule separating software, implementation and migration, recurring accounting or management labor, payment and banking charges, mailings, lockbox, resale work, collections, tax support, custom reports, cleanup, training, storage, integrations, data exports, annual increases, and termination assistance.
Smartwebs' current public pricing page distinguishes Core Management from MAX Management + Accounting and notes quote-based pricing, minimums, and implementation fees. PayHOA packaging and optional services should likewise be verified in the current proposal. Compare equivalent scope. A lower software price can cost more if volunteers must supply recurring labor or if the board purchases missing work later.
Run an implementation and portability rehearsal
Before signing, inventory owners, units, charges, payments, general ledger, chart of accounts, budgets, vendors, invoices, bank reconciliations, documents, requests, violations, communications, attachments, users, open tasks, and audit history. Define the conversion date, opening-balance approval, historical depth, owner validation, parallel testing, training, and first-close acceptance criteria.
Then request sample exports from the proposed configuration. Record whether each item is structured data, PDF, image, original attachment, or vendor-specific format. Confirm export fees, timing, administrator rights, read-only access, final accounting, payment shutdown, credential transfer, successor cooperation, and deletion or retention after termination. Portability should be tested while the relationship is healthy.
Choose software, accounting support, or full management deliberately
- Software only can work when the association has trained people, time, controls, continuity, and a documented close.
- Software plus outsourced accounting can work when the board retains operations but delegates reconciliations, ledger review, payables coordination, reporting, cleanup, and close continuity.
- Full association management may fit when the board also needs ongoing owner service, meetings, vendors, maintenance, inspections, governance, enforcement, and emergency coordination.
Put every recurring responsibility beside a named owner, frequency, deadline, evidence, backup, and fee. That responsibility matrix often makes the correct operating model clearer than a feature comparison.
Where Common Ledger fits
Common Ledger specializes in the accounting workflow around PayHOA: setup review, bank reconciliations, owner-ledger review, accounts payable and receivable oversight, reserve presentation, monthly board packets, cleanup, migration support, and virtual administration. For eligible service arrangements, Common Ledger can cover the PayHOA software cost when an association transitions to Common Ledger.
If a board is comparing Smartwebs with a PayHOA and Common Ledger model, compare the annual outcome: implementation, recurring labor, board workload, owner service, reconciled reports, controls, access, portability, and total event-based costs.